Cottonwood to decide whether to raise sales tax amid public support for increase

Cottonwood Police Chief Steve Gesell presents to council what a sales tax increase would do for Cottonwood PD during a work session last night. (VVN/Kelcie Grega)

Cottonwood Police Chief Steve Gesell presents to council what a sales tax increase would do for Cottonwood PD during a work session last night. (VVN/Kelcie Grega)

COTTONWOOD -- Cottonwood City Council will decide whether or not to increase the city’s sales tax next Tuesday, and if so, how much.

Right now, Cottonwood has a 3-percent sales tax. Combined with the state and county sales tax, it is around 9.35 percent. This rate hovers slightly below average for the region.

A full-service city, Cottonwood is one of the only municipalities of its size in the region that doesn’t have a property tax or a special district tax.

Sales tax increase scenarios between .25 and 1 percent were presented to council last week during two separate budget work sessions. Several city department heads spoke to council on Thursday on how a sales tax increase would benefit their department.

Community Service Manager Richard Faust spoke on behalf of the library, Parks & Recreation and custodial programs.

“With the library, our biggest concern is keeping what we have intact as well as looking into the future,” he said. “If the tax does increase, that would help that existing program to bring in additional services to the community.”

Faust also said with that state’s recent minimum wage increase, employees on the lower end of the pay scale are being paid just above those working part-time.

Police Chief Steve Gesell told council that as a taxpayer who has lived in and served in communities similar to Cottonwood that an “increase in a sales tax makes sense in this situation particularly because we are a regional hub.”

“You have people coming in, they’re buying goods and services and they’re spending their money in our community and quite frankly, it makes sense from a taxpayer standpoint to spread the burden beyond our own resident population.”

Noting a need for future funding, Gesell also referenced Cottonwood PD’s strategic plan which includes the construction of a consolidated property and evidence facility with office space for IT and Fire.

“That project alone is a $500,000 and that’s what we requested this year,” he said. “The construction costs are estimated to be $4.5 million.”

Public response

During both work sessions on Tuesday and Thursday, members of the public gathered inside council chambers with signs advocating for a .65-percent sales tax increase. Historically, this is an unusual move for citizens in the Verde Valley. In 2015, the Town of Camp Verde voted 4-3 to increase its sales tax by .65 percent. This ignited a recall effort that targeted four council members who voted for the increase: then-Vice Mayor Bruce George, Mayor Charlie German, and council members Jessie Murdock and Robin Whatley.  

While Cottonwood’s council chambers were filled with the public’s overwhelming support of a sales tax increase, not all constituents feel the same way, according to Council Member Deb Althouse.

“I’ve had people come up to me and say ‘I can’t believe you’re going to raise our sales tax and build a city hall,’” she said. “I don’t agree with the .65 percent increase, I think it’s too high.”

Althouse continued: “I think roads and sidewalks are way more important than a city hall and I think reserves are way more important than a lot of this other stuff, including some of the personnel requests.”

Another concern brought up by members of the public is how the sales tax affects groceries.

Phil Terbell, who owns a business in Cottonwood said during a call to the public Tuesday that he was concerned over how a potential sales tax increase would affect the price of food.

“That makes this a very regressive tax to the lowest income in our community,” he said. “I would consider that some consideration be put in there for removal of food tax.”

The issue of sales tax on food has been brought up to voters in the past with voters rejecting a repeal in 2001.

In an interview with the Verde Independent, Yavapai County Supervisor Randy Garrison, who used to serve on Cottonwood City Council said the city has gone out of its way to provide every department’s wish.

“They do it at an extreme,” he said. “At the end of the day, sometimes you just have to cut things. It’s the city’s financial responsibility to step back and look at what they can afford.”

Cottonwood City Council will meet again Tuesday at 6 p.m. to discuss possible direction on a sales tax. Council meets at the Chambers Building, located at 826 N. Main St.

For agendas and minutes, visit the City of Cottonwood website. Watch meetings online on the Verde Valley TV YouTube channel.

--Follow Kelcie Grega on Twitter @KelcieGrega

Comments

Comments are not posted immediately. Submissions must adhere to our Use of Service Terms of Use agreement. Rambling or nonsensical comments may not be posted. Comment submissions may not exceed a 200 word limit, and in order for us to reasonably manage this feature we may limit excessive comment entries.

pinonbistro 4 months, 1 week ago

The big issue for me is that the city is vulnerable to another economic downturn without a sales tax increase to fund reserves, infrastructure and pay down liabilities like the unfunded pension liabilities that are being passed on to towns by the state at the same time the state is reducing its funding to local cities.

And if you buy anything anywhere else in the Verde Valley you’re paying more—Camp Verde, Jerome, and Sedona all have higher sales taxes than Cottonwood even though they don’t have a rec center, transportation, airport, regional library etc. They all have some kind of city property tax, either general or special district, as well which we don't. It is amazing to me that we have been able to operate as well as we have for as long as we have. But it has taken its toll.

0

azsteve1962 4 months, 1 week ago

"Community Service Manager Richard Faust spoke on behalf of the library, Parks & Recreation and custodial programs. “With the library, our biggest concern is keeping what we have intact as well as looking into the future,” he said. “If the tax does increase, that would help that existing program to bring in additional services to the community."

So, folks that don't live in the area, and therefore don't use the services of the Library, should help pay for our Library with every retail purchase.

Got it. Makes perfect sense.

0

pinonbistro 4 months, 1 week ago

Yes, sales tax should pay for a regional library that serves many outside the Cottonwood city limits. Residents from Jerome, Cornville and the Verde Villages all use the library. Libraries are free to the user for the most part so the revenues have to come from somewhere. It makes sense that it funded from the broader sales tax base and not a more narrow Cottonwood city property or special district tax.

0