Commentary: Potential development threatens Verde River; will we protect it?
Future conversion of agricultural land to residential development in the Big Chino and lower Williamson Valleys, which overlie the Big Chino basin-fill aquifer, could cause the Verde River to be seasonally dry through Perkinsville.
Scientists estimate that groundwater from the Big Chino aquifer provides 80-86 percent of the water issuing from the Verde River’s headwater springs near Paulden. Verde River streamflow is supplied by base flow (groundwater exiting to the river) plus runoff from storms or snowmelt. Base flow provides roughly half the total annual streamflow in the Verde River from the Paulden streamgage (eight river miles below the headwater springs) through the Verde Valley.
Removing groundwater by pumping from an aquifer eventually decreases base flow in a connected stream by an amount approximately equal to the amount pumped. In a reach without base flow the river can flow only when runoff from storms or snowmelt is present.
A recent multiyear study estimated that water demand in 2050 in the general area of the Big Chino aquifer would be approximately 13,000 acre-feet per year (afy). This rate is identical to that of the lowest flows during the past eight summers at the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) Paulden streamgage and represents summer base flow. If this summer base flow is the new normal, and the anticipated 13,000 afy of water demand is supplied solely by pumped groundwater, a temporarily dry river from the headwater springs for about 24 river miles through the small community of Perkinsville is eventually to be expected every summer.
Two analyses based on a recently developed USGS groundwater flow model reflect additional demands on Verde River base flow. One analysis estimated that pumping that occurred through 2005 above the Paulden streamgage (i.e., in the Big Chino Valley and Little Chino sub-basin) would cause additional reduction in base flow at the streamgage of about 3,000 afy within a century. The second analysis estimated that pumping 12,000 afy from the Big Chino Water Ranch would reduce base flow at the Paulden gage by an additional 3,300 afy within 90 years. And, of course, there is still more land overlying the Big Chino aquifer that could be turned into developments of thousands of homes.
Sadly, there is no state or federal law that protects either the Big Chino aquifer or the perennial flow and riparian health of the Verde River. Citizen pressure is essential to support strategies such as:
• Changes in state law to protect Arizona’s few remaining healthy riparian reaches.
• Extreme water conservation to preserve groundwater.
• Enhanced re-use of treated wastewater.
• Zoning and funding to support continued ranching instead of new housing development.
Just as it’s important to plan for retirement before we’re elderly, the time for citizens to work for protection of the river is now!
Brian Studenka and Andrew Jamieson of ITC Holdings Corp. discuss the proposed Big Chino Valley Pumped Storage Project when the Citizens Water Advocacy Group meets Saturday, March 10. Details at www.cwagaz.org.
Edward W. Wolfe, Ph.D., is a retired U.S. Geological Survey geologist. His USGS work included, among a variety of projects, geologic investigations of the San Francisco volcanic field (northern Arizona) and of the Cedar Bench Wilderness and the adjacent part of he Verde Valley. For more than a decade, both singly and with retired USGS groundwater hydrologist William Meyer, he has written numerous articles and has given many presentations on the groundwater issues affecting the Verde River watershed and the Verde River. Wolfe was a founding member of the Citizens Water Advocacy Group’s Board of Directors, the former chairman of the Verde Watershed Association, former chairman of the Verde River Basin Partnership’s Technical Advisory Group, and former chairman of the Partnership’s Board of Directors. He is chairman of the Education Committee of CWAG.